Such an easy recipe. I creamed one of the cans with an 8oz block of cream cheese and 2tbsp of key lime juice then blended it with the rest of the filling. Came out to be creamy perfection.

My favorite Key Lime Pie recipe by far!

awesome!! perfect recipe

Seriously the best key lime pie I’ve ever had. I’ve made this three times now, exactly as the recipe is written, and it turns out perfectly every time. I use brown sugar instead of white in all of my crusts now, too. Thanks so much for posting this perfect recipe! It’s all I think of when key limes are back in stock during the warm months in my local grocery store.

Really easy and tastes fantastic.

Was wonderful. People thought I was so brilliant. Sheesh took 10 minutes. Will be a go to pie Jane Babcock

I have made this so many times. Everyone I know loves it. I use this pie crust for other pies too. It was amazing on the Dutch apple pie I made. I HIGHLY recommend this recipe. It is easy and SO delicious! Thank you so much for sharing!

This pie was delicious! After reading the posted reviews, I added more eggs to make sure the pie set up properly. I used 6 egg yolks and baked the pie for 20 minutes. It was perfect!

Followed recipe to a t and it was delicious!!! Thanks for sharing!

Amazing! As good as any key lime pie I’ve had anywhere!

Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Very, very sweet. I would try it with only one can of sweetened condensed milk next time not just for sweetness control but the amount of pie filling seemed like way too much. Crust was excellent and lime flavor was perfect. I used regular limes bc it’s what I had on hand. Thanks for the recipe tho!

It was kinda hard because we had to squeeze 8 limes to get 1 cup. We finally squeezed a cup and we did hard work but finally we got it.

Easy and delicious! Thank you for the recipe

Probably one of the easiest and best tasting pies I’ve ever made. I made it for my mother, she loved it too. I also added a little extra butter for the crush.

Little extra butter and it was good

Made it today for thanksgivingIt was a hit!! I modified it and made a pecan crust instead 10/10

Great, not modified, this the second time that I have used this recipe.

Great, I’m making it again

Perfect! Tasty and zesty

A great key like pie recipe. I used regular limes instead of key limes, and it still turned out great. This recipe is not as sweet as some other recipes, so the lime flavour actually comes through. Everyone at work loved it and I would recommend it.

Easy, tastes just like those I’ve had in Key West, well a bit different not due to recipe but because my local stores don’t carry Key Lime juice. All in all a very good recipe.

It was really good. Tasted just like Key Lime Pie should taste.

I made it according to the recipe and it was delicious and turned out perfect!

Worth the extra effort to make the home made crust

Great! One of my favorite pies. I can't believe I never made it cause people told me it was hard. Super easy will be made time after time.