Cookies and Cream Cookies Recipe | Yummly
AboutCareersContact UsFAQs
BookmarkletYum Button

Cookies and Cream Cookies

Wheeler: "The cookies were great! Just had an issue with th…" Read More
Read Directions
Add to Meal Planner

Add to Meal Planner


  • 2 3/4 cups all purpose flour
  • 1 tsp. baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp. baking powder
  • 1 cup unsalted butter (softened)
  • 1 1/2 cups white sugar
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 tsp. vanilla extract
  • 14 Oreo cookies
  • Did you make this?
    Add All to Shopping List
    Add to Meal Planner

    NutritionView More

    Unlock full nutritional details with subscription

    Calories1220Calories from Fat500
    Total Fat56g86%
    Saturated Fat32g160%
    Trans Fat
    Calories from Fat500
    Total Carbohydrate170g57%
    Dietary Fiber4g16%
    Vitamin A30%
    Vitamin C

    * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.


    Wheeler 5 months ago
    The cookies were great! Just had an issue with them melting together but that most likely my fault!
    Julie Davis 6 months ago
    Like a sugar cookie (not the cutout kind) plus Oreos. I almost burned up my kitchenaid stand mixer- it started smoking.
    Shari Alwee a year ago
    It turned out really well. I used 2 small eggs rather than 1 big one. But next time I am going to add a bit of salt.
    Juliana Bird a year ago
    they turned out great
    Rhea p. a year ago
    These were easy to make. Taste good, not too sweet even with the Oreos. I would mash the oreos first before mixing next time as I didn’t want to over mix the dough and by the time I mixed the whole Oreos, the dough was pretty thick. They’d didn’t flatten either but they were still a hit in my house.
    Molly Junquet a year ago
    These are my most requested cookies! So good
    Donna Lofgren 2 years ago
    Easy and yummy!! I like them even though I don’t like Oreos!
    Adams 2 years ago
    This was a hit. Follow instructions to a tea and it will turn out great. 3 days later and cookies was still go. My new favorite cookie.
    Monica 2 years ago
    Very delicious and very quick and easy to make. Would definitely recommend!!
    Nat 2 years ago
    ok as far as cookies go
    Ally Bustos 2 years ago
    Batter comes out pretty dry, just keep mixing for a few minutes and do not add extra liquid! Cookies came out pretty high and puffy, tasted kind of more doughy than like a cookie... didn’t taste bad but definitely didn’t taste like a normal cookie either. Not sure what went wrong here lol.
    Jonah Matson 2 years ago
    Delicious! FYI: The batter will be dry, so just mix it a bit longer, don't add more liquids!
    Gina 2 years ago
    Very good but the batter is a bit dry! I also put a few more Oreos than the directions said to so that could be why!
    KJunk Mendoza 2 years ago
    It was so yummy. Even with the slightly lower reviews I still took a chance. As I am writing this almost half the batch is gone. Delicious.
    Caitlin Madeiros 2 years ago
    The batter was a little dry, so I added some water and they flattened a bit better
    Andres Gonzalez 2 years ago
    They turned out delicious and chewy! 8 ingredients and 4 simple steps! I saw couple bad reviews and was very ify on making these. But put all the negative ratings aside and follow the steps, very easy to make.
    Amanda Topel 3 years ago
    Wouldn't make these again. The final result looked puffy, not like a cookie. Tastes very doughy. 🖓🖓🖓 Also, couldn't really taste the oreos.
    Me 3 years ago
    Yum yum. But needs more Oreos.
    Talya 3 years ago
    It came out ok I used margerine instead of butter and the cookies don’t taste as like cookies and cream as much as I’d like them to even tho I used 16 instead of 14 Oreos!!!! Other then that it was an easy to follow recipe and I’d still make them again
    Jenn 3 years ago
    These are THE best and easy, too!
    Yann Tastayre 3 years ago
    they turned out well. I'm sure theyll be a hit
    Michelle Aldrich 4 years ago
    These cookies are amazing. Make sure you follow the directions and don't over mix them. I did that the first time i made them and they came out hard but still tasted amazing. I've mixed it better the other times I've made them and they were chewy and delicious.
    Sons 4 years ago
    Not how I expected it to be at all. Does not look like the picture either.
    reid 4 years ago
    Thing and Crispy, but very delicious
    Jessica DeWitt 4 years ago
    I was really disappointed by this recipe. They were fairly dry, not chewy as advertised, and I did not find them particularly flavourful. Would not make again.
    Britney Jones 5 years ago
    Taste a mix between sugar cookies and Oreos. Husband loved these!
    Macky O 5 years ago
    I made these and they were so delicious! Soft, chewy, the oreo cookies melt in your mouth as well, i used Publix brand cookies and they were just as good. Will be making them again soon!