Surprising Things to Make with Mayonnaise

Surprising Things to Make with Mayonnaise

Create some kitchen magic with mayo in marinades, breading, and a moist and luscious spring strawberry cake

Healthier, better-tasting meals are easier than you think with help from Yummly! Try it free now.

Article, recipes, and photos by Ashley Strickland Freeman
Disclosure: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, meaning if you follow the link and make a purchase, Yummly makes a commission.

Mayonnaise is a magical ingredient to me. Yep, you read that right. The humble condiment used for making potato salad and slathering on your favorite ham sandwich can do so much more. In fact, last summer I published an entire cookbook dedicated to recipes with my beloved condiment — there’s even a dessert chapter. 

Before you go running for the hills, think of what mayonnaise is — a wonderfully thick and creamy emulsion of eggs and oil, plus a little acid like lemon juice or vinegar. All of those things are often found in many of the recipes we use every day, including sweets. For breakfast to dessert and everything in between, I’ve got a use for mayo. It’s great in marinades, can be used as a binder for breading, and is my secret to locking in moisture with cakes.

Besides all of the unexpected uses for mayonnaise, one thing I learned while writing my cookbook is that everyone is just as passionate about the brand of mayonnaise they buy as they are the football team they cheer for or how they pronounce “pecan.” Like many other Southerners, I grew up eating a certain brand of mayonnaise (Duke’s) and it’s still my preferred mayo to cook with. Unlike other commercial mayonnaise, Duke’s doesn’t contain sugar, making it a more versatile product for cooking and baking. If your favorite brand does have sugar, just keep that in mind when using it in recipes — you may need to adjust the amounts of salt or sugar called for. 

Something else I discovered while creating the book is that there are a lot of people who are scared of or have a strong aversions to mayonnaise. Is that you or someone you know? Well, I’m here to tell you that my husband was not into mayonnaise before, and now he’s a believer. 

Whether it’s my Grilled Chili-Lime Chicken Breasts with Mango Salsa, Sweet and Spicy Oven-Fried Shrimp Tacos, or Strawberry-Lemonade Cake, I challenge you to try one of the following unexpected ways to use mayonnaise. I may make a believer out of you too!

Jump ahead to:

Mayo surprise #1: Marinade magic >>

Grilled Chili-Lime Chicken Breasts with Mango Salsa >>

Mayo surprise #2: The key to crispy oven frying >>

Sweet and Spicy Oven-Fried Shrimp Tacos >>

Mayo surprise #3: Cake’s best buddy >>

Strawberry Lemonade Cake >>

More mayonnaise magic >> 

Note: The Yummly Meal Planner is available to paid subscribers. 

Mayo surprise #1: Marinade magic

Mayonnaise is awesome in marinades, especially for lean proteins like chicken breasts and pork loin or chops. Often by the time I’m able to brown thin cuts of meat, the inside is tough, overcooked, and dry. A marinade with mayonnaise in it, however, helps with the Maillard reaction, the browning reaction that occurs when meat is seared. That browning means flavor, so I love marinating those thin, lean cuts of meat in mixtures that include mayonnaise. Another bonus: Mayonnaise is a great carrier of flavors. Aromatics like garlic and herbs are more easily transferred to protein through the mayonnaise. Finally, the viscosity of mayonnaise mean it will stay stuck on the meat while it cooks, locking in flavor and moisture. 

A picture of turning chicken breasts in a marinade made with mayonnaise

Want to give it a try? My grilled chili-lime chicken breasts feature a mayonnaise marinade seasoned with chili powder, garlic, and lime. There’s a generous, sweet and crunchy mango salsa to spoon on top that can double as a salad. 

Grilled Chili-Lime Chicken Breasts with Mango Salsa

Yummly Original

Mayo surprise #2: The key to crispy oven frying

Fried foods are delicious, but who wants to heat up a vat of oil and fry at home? Not me! I used to have the hardest time “frying” things in the oven. The breading would always fall off, it wouldn’t get browned, or it wouldn’t be crispy. That’s where handy-dandy mayonnaise comes to the rescue. I use it as the batter in my breading routine, and it’s the glue that sticks everything together and makes the coating crispy. For baked onion rings, fried shrimp, and chicken fingers, mayonnaise is my go-to ingredient when it comes to oven frying. 

A picture of dipping breaded shrimp in a mayonnaise batter

 Mayonnaise is also the key ingredient in my Sweet and Spicy Oven-Fried Shrimp Tacos. These handheld tacos are an all-in-one dinner with a colorful, crunchy coleslaw and crispy sweet shrimp. Top the tacos off with a smoky, spicy sauce and watch them disappear!

Sweet and Spicy Oven-Fried Shrimp Tacos

Yummly Original

Mayo surprise #3: Cake’s best buddy

There’s nothing more frustrating to me than spending hours carefully creating a beautiful layer cake, only to have it come out dry as a bone. If I’m going to spend all of that time baking, the result has to be awesome. That’s why I add mayonnaise to cake batter. It’s my secret ingredient for ensuring the cake layers are moist and the crumb is tender. It also adds an extra layer of protection in case I overcook the cake by a minute or two. 

A picture of adding mayonnaise to cake batter

Do you love to bake or want to make your baking better? Give my Strawberry-Lemonade Cake a try. Luscious layers of strawberry cake are sandwiched with tangy lemon curd and pink-tinged strawberry-lemonade buttercream. Crowned with fresh strawberries and lemon zest curls, this cake is worthy of any celebration — from birthdays and baby showers to making it through a crazy Monday.

Though the cake gets its dense, moist texture thanks in part to mayonnaise, there are a couple of additional tricks to note here. The batter is flavored and colored with pureed fresh strawberries that are cooked down to a thick paste. The rich buttercream gets its rosy hue and bright flavor from freeze-dried strawberries, which are available in most supermarkets. 

Strawberry Lemonade Cake

Yummly Original

More mayonnaise magic

 Mayonnaise is great for marinades, breading, and cakes, but I also use it for:

  • Brushing on the outside of grilled cheese to cook up perfectly browned and crisp

  • Making flaky pie crust

  • Stirring into scrambled eggs to make them creamy

  • Tossing into streusel and crumble for fruit crisps

  • Adding to bread recipes to produce a tender crumb

  • Mixing into ground meat for flavorful and juicy burgers and meatballs

  • Making the fluffiest, creamiest mashed potatoes

See? Mayonnaise really is magical. Do you have other uses that I haven’t thought of? I’d love to hear about them. Tag @yummly on Instagram or Facebook.

Handy cooking tips and hacks from Yummly

From common tools used in new ways to faster techniques for daily cooking tasks, this next set of pro tips will make your life easier in the kitchen. 

• Genius and Totally Savory Ways to Use Your Bundt Pan

A Shredded-Chicken Kitchen Hack (And Two New Recipes to Use it in)

One Fast Hack for Easy-Peel Hard-Boiled Eggs5 Surprising Kitchen Hacks Using Your Colander

Chill Out! 6 Ice Cube Tray Hacks for a Cool, Convenient (and Zero-Waste) Summer